Private testing

If you do testing, then, like me, at one time you probably came up with a question "How do I test private methods?". The tricky part about private testing in static languages like java, is that you can't access private methods from outside.

There are couple of ways to test private methods. You can do it through reflection, you can easily find libraries which ease the syntactic pain. Or you can make it package-private, this way you can use them in your tests, but users of your library still can't see it (though it can turn your own package into a tangled mess).

And both things are WRONG! And many people know it. Go to stack overflow and you will see lot of upvoted results, how it is "implementation detail, don't test it".

In my opinion, you should test this kind of methods. If you closed your IDE/Editor of choice and opened Google, then chances are it's important enough to have a unit test. Do you smell it? I certainly do... And it's coming from your code!

If you want to test it - then it's important, if it's important, than why isn't it in your public API? Because class users don't care about, it's not class's responsibility. If it's not your class responsibility then go create a new one. Now you can test it all you want and then refer to it from the original class. Noisy teenager moved out from parents and has a separate life, the end.

At first glance people who use Ruby, Python and other dynamic languages without a strong notion of privacy are happily neglected to this problem. You can use private methods as easy as the ones that intended to be public. That's actually very scary. In Java on every method creation you have to decide whether it's private or public. If you don't have to do this you might end up with a bunch of monster classes (been there, done that, not proud of it).

Popular posts from this blog

HTTP server in Ruby 3 - Fibers & Ractors

Image
This is part #2. Head over to part #1 to learn about HTTP in Ruby. Motivation Historically Ruby's been lacking in the concurrency department. Ruby has "native" threads (prior to 1.9 there were only "green"), which means there can be multiple threads controlled by an OS, but only 1 thread can be executed at a time, this is managed via Global Interpreter Lock (GIL). However, native calls and I/O calls can be executed in parallel. During an I/O call, a thread gives up control and waits for a signal that the I/O has finished. This means I/O heavy applications can benefit from multiple threads. In this article we are going to explore different concurrency modes for our HTTP server: Single-threaded Multi-threaded Fibers Ractors Single-threaded Let's start simple and see how a single threaded HTTP server could look like ( full code ): def start socket = TCPServer.new(HOST, PORT) sock...
Read more

Next.js: restrict pages to authenticated users

Image
Many websites have pages that need to be restricted to authenticated users, for example profile pages or dashboards. Next.js web framework comes with a lot of functionality built-in JS compilation, rendering code on server and caching. When it comes to most other aspecs, it's up to a programmer to build, including such needed functionality as restricting access to some pages only to authenticated users. In this article we are going to build just that: a function that augments a page object, that could be used like that: Here's the implementation in TypeScript: In order to make it work on server we are going to need one more utility function fetchWithCookies . When making HTTP request from inside a Web Browser, the browser automatically sends cookies with each requests and then stores new cookies if a response comes in with set-cookie header. On server-side we need to build this feature ourselves, because neither Next.js nor NodeJS make any a...
Read more

Migration locks for TypeORM

Image
Schema migrations is a must-have functionality for any DB framework. TypeORM provides decent utilities for dealing with migrations, however having a decade of experience in Ruby on Rails I got really spoiled and take some features for granted. One of these features is locking a database while a migration going on so 2 processes running concurrently don't step on each other's toes. This is also important when you run migrations in Kubernetes before launching your app. I was really surprised to find out that this basic feature is not supported , so decided to implement it on my own. Implementation // typeormMigrationUtils.ts import { Connection, createConnection } from 'typeorm' import config from '../ormconfig' import CRC32 from 'crc-32' const MIGRATOR_SALT = 2053462845 async function withAdvisoryLock( connection: Connection, callback: () => Promise<void> ): Promise<boolean> { // generate a unique lock...
Read more